Twitter/X’s New Downvote/Upvote Feature: A Shift from Likes to Enhance Conversation Quality

In a significant update to its platform, Twitter/X has begun rolling out a downvote/upvote feature to replace the traditional “like” button, as reported by users and credible accounts on X in May 2025. This move, which has been in development since at least July 2024, aims to improve the quality of conversations by allowing users to privately flag low-quality or irrelevant replies while promoting more relevant content. The feature, currently in testing with select users, marks a shift in how engagement is measured on the platform and has sparked both enthusiasm and skepticism among its user base. This article explores the origins, mechanics, potential impacts, and user sentiments surrounding this change.

A History of Experimentation

Twitter/X’s exploration of a downvote/upvote system is not new. The platform has been testing similar features since 2021, when it introduced a Reddit-inspired downvote button for replies on iOS for a small group of users. At the time, Twitter emphasized that downvotes were private, not visible to the public or the tweet’s author, and were intended to help the platform understand which replies users found irrelevant or offensive. Upvotes, in contrast, were counted as likes and displayed publicly. The goal was to enhance conversation quality by surfacing more relevant replies without publicly shaming users, unlike Reddit’s public downvote counts.

In February 2022, Twitter expanded this test globally, making the downvote button available to more users on web, iOS, and Android. The platform reported that users primarily downvoted replies they deemed offensive or irrelevant, and the feature became the most common way to flag unwanted content. However, Twitter clarified that downvotes did not affect reply rankings or public metrics, and the feature remained experimental. By July 2024, code references to a dislike/downvote button were spotted in an X iOS app update, hinting at renewed efforts to refine the system.

The latest iteration, observed in May 2025, appears to be a more comprehensive overhaul, with posts on X suggesting that the downvote/upvote feature may replace likes entirely. Users have shared screenshots showing thumbs-up and thumbs-down icons, indicating a visual departure from the heart-shaped like button. While the feature is still in testing and not universally available, its rollout to Android and iOS users suggests a broader implementation is on the horizon.

How the Feature Works

Based on current reports and past tests, the downvote/upvote system operates as follows:

• Downvotes: Users can downvote replies they find irrelevant, offensive, or unhelpful by clicking a downward arrow or thumbs-down icon. Downvotes are private, meaning neither the tweet’s author nor other users can see them. This anonymity aims to prevent public shaming or targeted harassment, a concern raised during earlier tests.
• Upvotes: Upvotes replace or supplement the like button, depending on the test group. In previous experiments, upvotes were counted as likes and displayed publicly next to the reply. Recent posts suggest that upvotes may now be represented by a thumbs-up icon, aligning with the downvote’s visual style.
• Impact on Content: Twitter/X uses downvote data to refine its algorithm, reducing the visibility of low-quality replies and prioritizing those deemed relevant. Unlike Reddit, where downvotes directly affect a comment’s ranking, Twitter/X’s system does not currently display downvote counts or reorder replies publicly. However, the platform has indicated that downvoting helps customize users’ timelines by showing fewer similar replies in the future.
• Availability: The feature is currently limited to select users, with some reporting access on Android and iOS. Different test groups may see variations, such as up/down arrows, thumbs-up/down icons, or a downvote button alongside the traditional like button.

Twitter/X has been clear that the downvote is not a “dislike” button, despite user comparisons to Reddit and YouTube. Instead, it’s framed as a tool for flagging content that doesn’t contribute to meaningful conversation. The platform’s focus on privacy and algorithmic curation sets it apart from Reddit’s public voting system and YouTube’s dislike button, which creators can see privately.

Potential Benefits

The downvote/upvote feature could offer several advantages for Twitter/X and its users:

1. Improved Conversation Quality: By allowing users to privately flag irrelevant or offensive replies, the platform can better surface high-quality content. Twitter’s 2022 tests showed that downvoting was frequently used to mark offensive or off-topic replies, suggesting it could help reduce spam and toxicity.
2. Algorithmic Personalization: Downvote data enables Twitter/X to tailor users’ feeds, showing fewer replies similar to those downvoted. This could create a more relevant and enjoyable experience, particularly in long or viral threads.
3. Reduced Public Conflict: Unlike Reddit’s public downvote counts, Twitter/X’s private system avoids amplifying negativity or enabling pile-on behavior. This aligns with the platform’s efforts to foster healthier interactions, such as prompts to reconsider harmful replies.
4. User Empowerment: The feature gives users a more nuanced way to engage with content beyond liking or replying. As one user noted in 2022, downvoting offers a “clinical” way to express disapproval without resorting to aggressive comments.

Some users and experts see this as a step toward emulating Reddit’s effective content moderation, where human voting helps surface the best posts. If implemented thoughtfully, the feature could enhance discovery and make Twitter/X a more engaging platform.

Concerns and Criticisms

Despite its potential, the downvote/upvote feature has raised concerns among users and observers:

1. Potential for Misuse: Critics worry that downvoting could be weaponized to silence marginalized voices or suppress unpopular opinions. In 2022, some users flagged the risk of mass downvoting targeting groups like transgender individuals, a concern that persists with the 2025 rollout.
2. Increased Negativity: Replacing likes with a downvote/upvote system might shift the platform’s tone, emphasizing criticism over positivity. Posts on X in May 2025 expressed mixed feelings, with some users fearing it could “increase negativity or be misused.” Others, nostalgic for the heart-shaped like button, view the change as unnecessary.
3. Mental Health Impacts: While downvotes are private, knowing that replies can be downvoted could affect users’ mental health, particularly in a platform lacking Reddit’s anonymity. A 2021 survey by Twitter acknowledged this concern, asking users how they’d feel if their tweets were downvoted.
4. Implementation Challenges: The feature’s limited rollout and varying designs (e.g., arrows vs. thumbs) have caused confusion. In 2022, users criticized the downvote button’s placement next to the like button, finding it disorienting. Additionally, it’s unclear whether the feature will apply to main posts or remain reply-only, adding to uncertainty.
5. Algorithmic Bias: Relying on user votes to curate content risks reinforcing echo chambers or amplifying popular biases. As one user remarked in 2022, “We’re continuing to narrow the perspective of the world that we see.” Without transparency on how downvote data is used, users may question the algorithm’s fairness.

User Sentiment in May 2025

Posts on X from May 7, 2025, reflect a mix of curiosity, excitement, and apprehension about the feature. Accounts like @PopBase and @GoodMusicClubX announced the rollout, sparking discussions about its implications. Some users, like @4everwalkalone, welcomed the change as “an interesting change” that could boost engagement, though they noted Android users might lag in access. Others, such as @urgirlwanjiru and @offlThangaraj, simply confirmed the feature’s arrival, indicating its visibility to a broader audience.

However, not all reactions were positive. @gaga_replay’s query to @PopBase prompted a cautious response from @grok, noting that while the feature could improve content quality, it risks increasing negativity if misused. This sentiment echoes earlier concerns from 2021 and 2022, when users feared the feature might enable anonymous harassment or prioritize divisive content. The lack of official confirmation from Twitter/X as of May 7, 2025, fuels speculation, with users relying on screenshots and anecdotal reports to understand the feature’s scope.

Comparison to Other Platforms

Twitter/X’s downvote/upvote system draws inevitable comparisons to Reddit and YouTube, but key differences highlight its unique approach:

• Reddit: Reddit’s public upvote/downvote system ranks comments based on net votes, fostering community moderation but also enabling pile-ons. Twitter/X’s private downvotes and lack of public tallies aim to avoid this, focusing on algorithmic curation rather than public judgment.
• YouTube: YouTube’s dislike button, made private in 2021 to reduce targeted attacks, still allows creators to see dislike counts. Twitter/X’s downvotes are fully private, even to authors, prioritizing user feedback over creator metrics.
• Facebook: Facebook tested downvotes but opted for emoji reactions to avoid negativity. Twitter/X’s earlier experiments with emoji reactions suggest it may integrate similar options alongside downvoting.

These distinctions reflect Twitter/X’s attempt to balance user feedback with the platform’s open, real-time nature, though it must navigate the same pitfalls that led YouTube and Facebook to limit or abandon downvoting.

The Road Ahead

As of May 7, 2025, Twitter/X has not officially confirmed whether the downvote/upvote feature will permanently replace likes or how it will evolve. The feature’s testing phase, limited to select users, suggests the platform is still gathering data to refine its implementation. Past experiments indicate Twitter/X is cautious about public reception, with concerns about mental health, misuse, and algorithmic bias shaping its approach.

The success of this feature will depend on several factors:

• Transparency: Twitter/X must clarify how downvote data influences content ranking and address concerns about bias or suppression.
• User Education: Clear communication about the feature’s purpose and mechanics can reduce confusion and encourage constructive use.
• Balancing Positivity and Critique: Retaining a positive user experience while introducing critical feedback tools will be crucial to avoid alienating users accustomed to the like button.
• Scalability: Expanding the feature to main posts, as hinted in some reports, could amplify its impact but also its risks.

Elon Musk’s vision for X as a platform for free speech and diverse perspectives adds another layer of complexity. While the downvote/upvote system could align with goals of improving content quality, it must avoid stifling debate or amplifying mob behavior, a challenge Musk’s leadership has faced in other platform changes.

Conclusion

Twitter/X’s downvote/upvote feature represents a bold attempt to reimagine engagement on the platform, moving away from the simplistic like button toward a more nuanced system of user feedback. By prioritizing conversation quality and algorithmic personalization, the feature has the potential to make Twitter/X a more relevant and respectful space. However, its success hinges on addressing concerns about misuse, negativity, and transparency, which have dogged similar experiments on other platforms.

As the rollout continues, user feedback will play a critical role in shaping the feature’s future. For now, the Twitter/X community watches closely, weighing the promise of better conversations against the risks of a more critical platform. Whether this change becomes a permanent fixture or another fleeting experiment, it underscores Twitter/X’s ongoing quest to balance openness with quality in the ever-evolving world of social media.

Sources:

• Mashable, “Twitter begins testing Reddit-like downvote system for iOS users,” July 21, 2021
• The Verge, “Twitter is testing upvote and downvote buttons on tweets,” July 21, 2021
• TechCrunch, “Twitter tests Reddit-style upvote and downvote buttons,” July 21, 2021
• USA Today, “Twitter’s new downvote feature is nothing like Reddit, YouTube,” February 5, 2022
• Kapwing, “How to Downvote on Twitter (and Why You Should),” June 27, 2022
• HeyOrca, “The most important X (Twitter) updates from 2025,” April 30, 2025
• NewsBytes, “Twitter may introduce emoji reactions, downvote option for tweets,” March 25, 2021
• NBC News, “Twitter is testing downvotes. Experts are split on how they would affect the platform,” July 22, 2021
• 9to5Mac, “Twitter downvotes give us what we don’t want, as we still wait for Edit button,” February 4, 2022
• The Washington Post, “Twitter’s downvote button: Everything you need to know,” February 4, 2022
• MakeUseOf, “Twitter Is Testing Upvotes and Downvotes on Reply Tweets,” July 22, 2021
• The Verge, “Twitter expands downvote test worldwide,” February 4, 2022
• TechXplore, “Twitter’s new downvote feature is nothing like Reddit, YouTube,” February 7, 2022
• Engadget, “Twitter’s ‘downvote’ button test begins rolling out globally,” February 4, 2022
• SunriseGeek, “X is Introducing a New Feature: Its Dislike Button For Replies,” July 15, 2024
• @PopBase, May 7, 2025
• @4everwalkalone, May 7, 2025
• @GlobalUpdates24, May 7, 2025
• @offlThangaraj, May 7, 2025
• @urgirlwanjiru, May 7, 2025
• @GoodMusicClubX, May 7, 2025
• @grok, May 7, 2025
• @grok, May 7, 2025